The giving season is almost upon us, and so millions of Americans soon will turn to Charity Navigator or GuideStar for help in vetting nonprofits. Unfortunately, neither is entirely up to the job.
That once again became clear to me when I began looking into a charity called Alley Cat Allies that, by coincidence, is headquartered just a few miles from my home in Bethesda, MD. Alley Cat Allies is, to be blunt, a mess. Even so, it has been given the best possible scores by both Charity Navigator and GuideStar.
This is a big problem for the nonprofit sector, and one that deserves more attention from foundations (Hewlett, Gates, Raikes) that are trying to improve the practice of philanthropy and the performance of nonprofit groups.
The Chronicle of Philanthropy just published my story about Alley Cat Allies, a group that has been around for decades and advocates for feral cats. Alley Cat Allies is not a mom-and-pop charity; it brought in nearly $10m last year.
The story is behind a paywall, so you’ll have to trust me when I tell you that Alley Cat Allies has engaged in a variety of questionable dealings in recent years. It used charitable donations to acquire two residential property in Arlington, VA, including the home next door to the home of its executive director, Becky Robinson. (I’m told this helped resolve a dispute with the neighbor over Robinson’s backyard full of cats, but could not confirm this.) Amazingly, in neither case did Robinson inform the full board that Alley Cat Allies was buying the properties. (One board member learned about the real estate dealing from me!) The board chair, a woman named Donna Wilcox, for years has been a full-time, paid employee of Alley Cat Allies, which is crazy. How can a paid staff member evaluate or provide oversight of her boss? (Wilcox left her job days ago, she wrote on Facebook.) The board, which includes some well-credentialed folk, including a PhD economist with the FDIC, has not met this year. Top executives get generous pay. The organization pursued a costly copyright lawsuit against a former freelance photographer and his wife, for what appears to me to be no good reason. Employees say it’s an awful place to work. Etc.
And yet….those stellar rankings.
I write this not to critique Michael Thatcher, CEO of Charity Navigator, or Jacob Harold, CEO of GuideStar, who are doing the best they can with limited resources. I like and admire both of them. But they don’t have anywhere near enough money or staff to independently examine hundreds or thousands of nonprofits. They might have uncovered the governance problems at Alley Cat Allies by closely reading its Form 990, but they could not have known that the charity was buying the house next door to its executive director. To their credit, neither claim to be watchdogs, although they are often portrayed or perceived that way.
What can the charitable sector do to better evaluate nonprofits? That’s hard to say. Maybe community foundations could come up with lists of best local nonprofits. Maybe other funders could focus on niches that they care about, by evaluating the education nonprofits that try to help poor kids get through college, or the climate-change advocacy groups, and then recommend the best of them, explaining why. (Animal Charity Evaluators does this for animal welfare groups, but, of course, that didn’t stop donors from sending money to Alley Cat Allies.) Independent evaluations collected by others could then be distributed on broad-based platforms such as Charity Navigator and GuideStar. Maybe there’s an opportunity here for Feedback Labs or the broader feedback movement, to reward well-run nonprofits that listen to those they are trying to serve.
Meantime, what’s a donor to do? By all means, consult Charity Navigator and GuideStar. They will spotlight problems with a nonprofit after those problems become public, and they will help you, as a donor, avoid fake charities that spend most of their budgets on fundraising. But do a little of your own digging, too. Research a charity with as much seriousness as you’d research a car, a vacation or, for some, a restaurant. Or give to a nonprofit that you know well and trust. Or turn to organizations like GiveWell or the Center for High Impact Philanthropy, which identify a small number of effective charities.
Do keep giving if you can. Thankfully, charities like Alley Cat Allies are the exception and not the rule.
23 thoughts on “Alley Cat Allies, and the charity “watchdogs” that aren’t”
After a newstory broke about cats I was caring for being shot by a park district in Oakland, California, I was contacted by Becky Robinson and her team. They promised that they would get justice for my cats and make sure this never happened again. I was vulnerable as hell. The hounded me for pictures and descriptions of each cat killed. It was so hard to do this but I did. Of course, Callie Gerber called me every day telling me that Becky needed those pictures to get justice. I stupidly signed a form they pressed me to sign which gave them rights to use the pictures. The paperwork said I would receive 200 worth of cat food. I didn’t care about the cat food but guess what, they didn’t even send that until much later but I sent it back. They only sent it because I was horrified to see that all they were doing was campaigning with the pictures of my dead cats and telling people they needed generous donations to get justice. They did send someone out to do a video of me about the cats.They used the video for donations too. But they kept telling me that I should not speak at board meetings for the park district so I could let the public know what happened. They were adamant that I not speak with Oakland Animal Services, The District Attorney, the Police Department or Internal Affairs at the Park District. Then, they are selling tshirts and coffee mugs about my cats being killed. All the while I kept hoping they were going to do something. They boasted about their National following. Becky said no one could help get justice better than they could. I asked them about getting video footage from a car dealership next to where the cats had been killed. They told me to hold off. Then they said they were doing everything possible. The only thing they did was use my babies to raise money. I finally realized this and started working with the local shelter to actually work and get the story out. AlleyCat Allies cost me critical time. The dealership said they would have had video at the time I had asked AlleyCat about it but now it is erased. They called me constantly to tell me not to speak out. They convinced me that my voice would only hurt the chances of getting justice. When they finally sent the catfood because I used that as a demand that they take the photos down, they sent sample sized bags of a food I would never give my cats. I gave it to a local charity group because my heart was sick that they used my pain and the cats death to profit. Still, over the weeks I continued to send them information I was gathering though public record requests. They would never respond. They state on their website they are working day and night for the cats killed by the Parks but if they are, why didn’t they use any of the information I sent them? I found a person to do a story and he has tried contacting them for comment. They do not respond. The only decent thing they have done is to take down the pictures of my cats because I threatened to sue them. I want to file a complaint but I’m also up to my elbows trying to get back the time they took away to advocate on behalf of the cats killed by East Bay Regional Parks in Oakland. AlleyCat Allies took advantage and I wish they would return money to people who thought they were helping to make sure cats are never shot again. This organization is worse than any gangster who ever took advantage of a victim. They are beyond horrible people.
Thanks for all the pro & con info. I was ready to write a check for the cute calendar they sent me. BUT instead I will continue to contribute to my local people.
Sadly, I didn’t see this article until after I did a birthday fund raiser and raised $100s for them. I never even got a acknowledgement email from them. Not terribly professional of them. Will be raising for a different non-profit this year.
That’s inexcusable. So sorry to hear that.
Yes i had my doubt about aca. I never donated to them. When i wrote to them about BIRTH CONTROL ANIMAL FOOD THAT I WANT TO BRING BACK ON THE MARKET AND HAVE X AMOUNT OF DOLLARS TO DO THIS WITH BUT NEED TO HIRE A REAL PERSON WHO CAN HELP WITH MY LIFE TIME DREAM I RUN THE CITIZENS COMMITTEE FOR ANIMAL RIGHTS IN NY $% YEARS A PRIVATE ORG THAT DOES NOT RAISE MONEY> WE DO GIVE AS BEST BWE CAN BUT I TRY TO BE CAREFUL ABOUT WHO I GIVE TOO NEVER BE TO NORTH SHORE ANIMAL LEAGUE OR BEST FRIENDS ETC> thank for info i can be reached at 718 426 1896 anytime from email@example.com
Marc, the fact that you allow the offensive, violent, hateful and threatening remarks of would-be cat-exterminator “Nature Advocate” to remain on your site negates any rational content you may have intended to share.
Alley Cat Allies are the biggest scam out there. I lived just about 4 blocks away from their offices and for years I thought they were friendly until they tricked me out of my 2 Siamese kittens! Catherine Brown drove me and my kittens to Caring Hands Animal hospital for medical fostering for 3weeks, as I was going to the hospital myself. Charlene Pedrolie the COO of Alley Cat Allies had them taken away from the hospital. She argued and cursed at my daughter. I took them to court and somehow the judge dismissed my case. I’ve been through their offices many times and they are charlatans, masters of deceptions and they LIE! To think my daughter and I sent donations to them! Spread the word! Go on Yelp and Glassdoor.com! And Google Charlene Pedrolie who worked in NYCACC and put animals to death daily even when rescue groups and adopters put holds on the animals!
I live in NJ, near Atlantic City, and we agree that ACA has done little to care for the boardwalk cats properly or to improve the lives of cats that need TNR in that area. Yet, they have a 4 star rating on Charity Navigator. They have stopped doing any TNR and we wonder what they are using the 6 million they have in assets for. Apparently to buy property like the article above indicated.
You are so write. It’s inexcusable they are allowed to continue. Searching for Charlene Pedrolie will absolutely pull up some horrid things. It’s ironic that they don’t even list her on the Allie Cat Website. No where to be found. Not in leadership or anywhere. Must be trying to hid something.
Unfortunately I had a similar thing happen to me by a rescue group. It’s very very strange & sad & beyond that actually-it’s heart crushing & I cry every night for my kittens. And morning. It causes me chest pains-it is unimaginable to me that somebody would lie & take somebody else’s kittens, say they’re returning them & then keep them. The worst is these criminals then gaslight you & act as if you’re in the wrong…absolutely devastating
Nature Advocate has real issues. Scary….
I’m truly surprised that you people are just now finding out about the con-job that Becky Robinson is running. I archived “The Better Business Bureau” reviews of her years ago. Then suddenly, when I made that review known everywhere publicly, BBB no longer reviewed her financial antics. I guess she hired some lawyers to make them stop. Instead, she quickly bought 5-stars on Charity Navigator and promoted that news everywhere.
Here’s one of the pages I archived long ago.
Did you know that they only have about 70,000 followers and supporters on their facebook account? (Contrary to the 490+ thousand that they display.) The number hovered between 60,000 and 70,000 for more than a decade. I showed everyone that, from those numbers, less than 0.0007% of the population supports her and her vermin cats and this is precisely why less than 1% of all stray cats in any community can ever be trapped, there’s that few that care about community-vermin cats. Around that time (when I was proving how few support her beliefs) there were news announcements of how people on facebook were buying fake-like software and hiring click-farms. She found out how to instantly increase her popularity with some of that donation money. Her “likes” and “followers” started to steadily increase by 1,000 new followers and likes per day after those news announcements. Incremented so steady that you could set your calendar date by each new batch of 1,000 followers and likes. She now boasts 490+ thousand followers, of which only 70,000 are real people.
I have no point of view on feral cats or the ability of organizations to inflate their Facebook followers (if that is indeed what happened) but thank for posting that BBB Wise Giving Review from 2012. Interesting to see that the governance failures surfaced more than five years ago and have not been corrected or reflected in the scores for Alley Cat Allies on Charity Navigator or GuideStar.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are probably already aware of this site (having mentioned “Employees say it’s an awful place to work.”), but whenever reading her advertising for new employees on her facebook page, this is a fun one to go to to see why there’s another huge employee turnover — again (more than once a year is not uncommon). https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Alley-Cat-Allies-Reviews-E848138.htm
There was at one time about 50 reviews there but some of the most lengthy, terrible, and revealing ones have since disappeared. Like the one where one employee was fired for bringing a cheese-sandwich to work. In direct violation of Becky’s dictatorial vegan work-rules. (I guess this doesn’t apply to all that beef, pork, chicken, and tuna cat-food that they feed the office work-cats.) No doubt she sometimes uses her paid staff to flag posts there for deletion while adding their own rare few rave reviews.
In any case, some of your readers might get a chuckle out of what some of her past employees have to say about signing up working for that manipulative and perpetually deceptive con-artist. Without signing up for an account there to read more than page-1 of the reviews, you’ll still get to see the post subject titles on further pages of reviews, which pretty much says it all anyway. (Though reading them in-full can be quite entertaining.)
It’s the new money-making scam. Torture cats to death with TNR and
then as they die-off from “loving and humane TNR attrition” then
exploit their tortured bodies in the media for even more! You too can
become a deceptive, manipulative, and morally reprehensible
multimillionaire like Becky Robinson did by following this
Read for yourself how Becky Robinson is conning everyone out of
millions of dollars every year by making sure cats die in the streets.
Click to access Alley-Cat-Allies-Form-990-FY16.pdf
She’s paying herself and friends yearly salaries of $200K and then
jet-setting around the world on a permanent vacation using even more
donations for that. Ask her about the $3M of those over $38M in
donations that she’s taken-in in the last 5 years that were dumped
into the stock-market. HSUS was fined nearly $16M in 2012 for engaging
in the very same practices as she.
More gut-wrenching laughable; Becky Robinson is a strict vegan, yet
has no problem torturing 2,400M birds and 12,300M other animals to
death YEARLY with her cats. She even tortures millions of cats each
year with her TNR attrition (becoming road-kill, ripped in half by
predators, death by poison or gunshot, slow death by infections and
diseases, etc.). Aside all the cats that she tortures to death with
TNR-attrition, that’s 6.6 MILLION birds PER DAY and 33.7 MILLION other
animals PER DAY that she guts alive and skins alive with her
And whales, seals, dolphins, marsupials, manatee, inland and
sea-otters, and large cats she is killing worldwide by spreading T.
gondii and feline diseases. She’s even killing rare Florida Panthers
with feline-specific diseases spread by her cats (confirmed by genetic
tracing back to the house-cat that killed them).
Or those boiled-alive animals with a “Cat Food!” label that she
gleefully accepts from PestSmart and is turned into TNR-grants to
perpetuate the Kill-Animals-for-Kitties gravy-train profiteering.
She’s a Typhoid-Mary Vegan destroying BILLIONS of animals. The
absolute worst carnage and torturing of animals in the history of
humanity being single-handedly caused by A VEGAN.
I’m really surprised that every last vegan on earth hasn’t
synthetic-tarred and faux-feathered her yet.
It’s a real shame that people like you would take a really serious topic as an opportunity to grandstand about anti-TNR stuff. There are plenty of real, legitimate concerns about this organization and the people in charge of it. Leave your weird agenda out of it.
The FACT that you are torturing to death over 40 MILLION animals to death DAILY (just in the lower-48 of the USA alone) with your community-vermin cats isn’t a serious issue for you? Of course it isn’t “serious” for you, is it. This is why everyone is now realizing that the only solution is to destroy every last free roaming cat, collared or not, because stray collared cats are the very source of every last community-vermin feral cat. If we don’t destroy the stray collared ones too then we’ll have done absolutely nothing to solve the worldwide ecological disaster that people like you have created and perpetuate with your TNR con-game. NOT ONE community, ANYWHERE on earth has reduced cat populations through the use of TNR. Not even in the UK where they invented and have been practicing that lie have they managed to reduce cats. They’ve only DOUBLED cat populations in sixty years of TNR. And let us not forget that their practice of TNR also drove their ONE AND ONLY native wildcat species to extinction too. Nice plan! Promote TNR some more. How many more species are you going to happily drive to extinction with your invasive-species community-vermin cats.
I agree it is not a good organization and I don’t believe in TNR. If you care about animals, cats and wildlife, then keep the cats in a proper and large enclosure so you can care for them when they get sick or a hurricane is coming to Atlantic City or people are killing them on the boardwalk. TNR is torture. TNK — trap neuter keep them safe.
I DO believe in TNR and have practiced it in my own neighborhood and it does work. It’s also clear that you have the anti-cat agenda (cats are bad because they eat birds) behind your current complaints. I do not know the people at the ACA personally but nothing here is proof of your complaint. Cats do need meat and cannot be vegetarian. That is simply a fact. I love birds as well as cats but it’s ridiculous to claim such a high number of bird deaths to cats alone with no actual proof. I have cared for several feral cats for years and there is simply no pile of dead birds in my neighborhood.
Total eradication would last about a minute to solve the PERCEIVED problem of free roaming cats. you would have to eradicate all humans who swear they will keep the neutered and vaccinated kitten INSIDE AND LOVED forever and a day. That lasts until they move, they develop an allergy to the cat or refuse to clean the litter box of the beloved family member. You see the holes in TNR, how can you be so naive about human nature as you so rationally (hmmm?) credit every domestic, friendly or feral for the end of the world humans have pretty much assured already. As an independent TNR person I have seen first hand the vacuum effect at many businesses and apartment complexes….it requires at least the same if not more vigilent maintenace. The best TNR people monitor colonies and trap newcomers and the sick or injured but outside life SUCKS as a lifelong solution for free roaming cats for the same reason teenagers and olf folks should not drive cars.)
As for TNK, I LOVE it but please think like a city planner for just a moment, not to mention the cost of real estate here in Southern CA. Maybe we could riase enough money to have that safe, fenced area for 40, 60, even 100 cats (check out Cat House on the Kings), that is heaven…..until we run out of space next week or next month. As much as I LOVE, CHERISH AND ADVOCATE for TNR M (monitor and maintain) free roaming, often abandoned cats I would support Nature Advocate’s eradication proposal OR the TNK proposal if either could be implemented in a week and shown to 100% solve the problems of outside cats and kittens. SO IMPLEMENT YOUR IDEAS BUT UNTIL THEN IT’S ANOTHER 30 YEARS OF TNRM FOR ME while the war of statistics continues and innocents die daily for a million ridiculous reasons.
And please support (0% overhead/admin) donations to OC Community Cats.
I may need to get a subscription to read the full article. Thanks for all your work, A quick note tho- Animal Charity Evaluators doesn’t really evaluate AR groups through a matrix of best practices but instead through what they determine to be most effective and then they recently started checking those groups for good management practices. I’m sure they do some thorough evaluations but bc of their premise they are unable to evaluate groups that are doing work that doesn’t fit their narrow matrix, eg sanctuaries. They’ve also led to further consolidation of resources to a few groups including HSUS and MFA (prior to your reporting and the restructuring).
In Atlantic City, the volunteers who take care of feral cats are the ones who need financial support. They do the trapping, pay for spay/neutering, buy all the food, and pay the vet bills. They do it all out of their own pocket for the concern and love of cats. Yet, Alley Cats takes credit for it and showcases these cats to promote their own agenda.
These local volunteers are the ones that should be receiving much needed financial help.
You are so correct Wilda! Alley CatvAllies take the credit what us volunteers do! I’m on the front lines every day 365, feeding, trapping, building shelters, taking the cats off the streets and out of shelters.
I’ve even volunteered with Alley Cat Allies September 2014, putting together packages to go out to people around the USA and elsewhere to ask for donations! They’re so unethical it’s scary. I’ve been in contact with people who worked with Charlene Pedrolie in NYACC who resigned because of her taking adoption/rescue $$ and putting those cats and dogs to death anyway! It was even an ongoing article on her in a Brooklyn newspaper several years ago.
Alley Cat Allies cannot be trusted.